John Adams, Abigail Adams, and The Balance of Liberty & Power, and the Constitution

 John Adams believed that power must be continuously checked and balanced to preserve liberty, which he considered fragile and constantly under threat. He advocated for a government of laws, not men, achieved through a structured system of separation of powers and a mixed government. 

Key Tenets of Adams's Philosophy
  • Inherent Desire for Power: Adams held a somewhat pessimistic view of human nature, believing that "all men would be tyrants if they could". He frequently stated that "power must never be trusted without a check" and that "the jaws of power are always open to devour".
  • Separation of Powers and Checks and Balances: To counter the natural inclination toward arbitrary power, Adams was a primary proponent of a tripartite government (executive, legislative, and judicial branches), each independent and able to restrain the others. He argued for a bicameral legislature to balance the interests of the wealthy (aristocracy/Senate) and the common people (House of Representatives), ensuring no single faction or branch could dominate.
  • Rule of Law: For Adams, the ultimate goal was a "government of laws, and not of men". The judicial branch played a crucial role in impartially administering justice and protecting individual rights against both governmental overreach and the "clamors of the populace".
  • Informed and Virtuous Electorate: Adams stressed that "liberty cannot be preserved without a general knowledge among the people". He viewed public education and a moral, virtuous citizenry as essential for countering corruption and the threats of an unbridled elite.
  • Property Distribution: Influenced by James Harrington, Adams believed that broad land ownership was essential for balancing political power. The widespread distribution of property would prevent economic power from concentrating in a few hands, which would otherwise lead to an oligarchy or tyranny.
  • Vigilance: His guiding maxim for preserving liberty was Obsta principiis—"nip the shoots of arbitrary power in the bud". He urged constant vigilance against the "first approaches of arbitrary power". 
In essence, Adams sought to harness the natural conflicts in society by using institutional design to force competing interests to moderate their passions and compromise for the common good, thereby preserving liberty. 

Abigail Adams believed that power and liberty must be balanced and well-regulated by just laws to prevent the natural human tendency toward domination from resulting in tyranny. She viewed arbitrary or unlimited power as inherently dangerous and a threat to liberty. 
Key Thoughts on Power and Liberty
  • Balance of Power and Liberty: In a letter to John Adams in May 1776, she uses a notable maxim: "Power and Liberty are like Heat and moisture; where they are well mixt every thing prospers, where they are single, they are destructive". This highlights her belief that neither power nor liberty should exist without the other as a check.
  • A Natural Propensity for Domination: Abigail firmly believed that "all Men would be tyrants if they could" due to a "natural propensity in Humane Nature to domination". This conviction led her to argue strongly for legal and structural checks on power, rather than relying solely on the virtue of individuals in government.
  • Rule of Law as Security: She argued that liberty can only exist in a government administered by "general stated Laws". In a 1795 letter, she expresses reliance "upon the Law" alone for security against ambition and arbitrary constitutional laws, not the presumed integrity of the rulers.
  • Representation and Consent: In her famous "Remember the Ladies" plea, she tied the concept of liberty directly to the principle of "no voice, no representation". She warned that women, if not given a voice in the new code of laws, would "foment a rebellion" and not hold themselves bound by laws they did not consent to, effectively paralleling the colonists' arguments against British rule.
  • Universal Principle of Liberty: She extended her thoughts on liberty beyond women's rights, writing, "I have sometimes been ready to think that the passion for Liberty cannot be Eaquelly Strong in the Breasts of those who have been accustomed to deprive their fellow Creatures of theirs". This shows her understanding that true liberty must apply universally, or its proponents are hypocritical in their calls for freedom. 
In essence, Abigail Adams advocated for a system where power was carefully limited by law and balanced by the rights and representation of all people, as she believed unchecked power inevitably leads to abuse. 

Yes, Abigail Adams was a Federalist. Her political beliefs aligned with the Federalist Party, which her husband, John Adams, led. She supported her husband's Federalist policies, acted as a partisan symbol for the party as First Lady, and even wrote essays to defend the party's positions against Republican opponents like Thomas Jefferson. 
  • Strong political alignment: Abigail Adams's letters and writings clearly show her commitment to the Federalist cause.
  • Partisan role: She embraced her role as First Lady to be a public and partisan symbol for the Federalist Party.
  • Defended Federalist positions: She wrote an essay defending the party and criticizing the Jeffersonian Republicans, arguing against hypocrisy and for fair treatment of the new administration.

Comments